Tuesday, 2 July 2019

Press statement

MESTECC Must Reject Lynas’ Appeal - The Path is now Clear for Lynas to Ship Back Its Toxic Waste 

28th June 2019


Closed-door Hearing Between Lynas and AELB


Today is the hearing date for Lynas’ appeal against the decision by the Minister for Environment, Science, Technology and Climate Change (MESTECC) YB Yeo Bee Yin last December. She has imposed two conditions for the renewal of Lynas’ license as follows – see also Screenshot1 on page 5 of this press statement:

(i) to submit an action plan by the 15th February to remove its scheduled waste (NUF) from the premises of the Lynas Advanced Material Plant (LAMP), accumulated over the years amounting to 1.15 million tonnes as at September 2018; and

(ii) to remove the waste from the water-leached purification (WLP) stream from Malaysia, in accordance with Lynas’ own written undertakings given in 2012. Lynas’ temporary storage licence for this waste expires on 2nd September.

The WLP waste contains a significant amount of long-living low-level radioactive thorium, toxic uranium[1], toxic heavy metals and chemicals. Many of the toxic elements are cancer causing substances that need to be isolated from the biosphere. The WLP waste is essentially a toxic waste.

SMSL is disappointed that the hearing is a closed-door meeting between Lynas and AELB. Mr Tan Bun Teet, chairman for SMSL commented, “Concerned residents are a key stakeholder. A public-interest civil society group like SMSL should be a party to the appeal since the decision will affect Malaysia’s future, citizens’ health and well-being.”

Lynas Must Remove its WLP Waste from Malaysia

Removing the WLP waste has been written into the license condition by AELB in 2012 – see TOL2 or page 2 of the TOL attached. This condition has been promoted and highlighted by several BN Ministers with the blessing of the previous Cabinet under former PM Najib – see attached public statement. Specifically, it has referred to it “…as a specific condition that the company removes all the residue generated by LAMP out of Malaysia. This includes all products made from the residue. The Cabinet has also endorsed this condition. “

The BN Ministers then went further to assured members of the public that: “Should Lynas fail to comply with this condition, the Atomic Energy Licensing Board (AELB) is empowered, under section 22 of the Atomic Energy Licensing Act 1984 (Act 304), to suspend or revoke the TOL and order Lynas to immediately cease operation. “

AELB is Not Independent, Objective or Professional

Mr Hon Kai Ping, SMSL’s legal adviser lamented, “Having witnessed years of prevarication and non-disclosure by AELB, against IAEA’s recommendations; and its bending backwards to accommodate Lynas against its own regulation and licence conditions. We have no confidence whatsoever that AELB can be independent, objective or professional in its dealings with Lynas. It has been complicit, appearing as it were on behalf of Lynas during past road shows in the face of strong opposition from the people and at various public forums over the years.”

Essentially, Malaysia has no credible radiation protection agency as AELB has continued to shift its own safety limits and precautionary safeguards in order to accommodate Lynas.

AELB Failures Resulted in Groundwater Contamination

“It is precisely because of AELB’s negligence and failure to enforce the law and to ensure that Lynas comply with its licence conditions that half a million tonnes of toxic radioactive[2] waste has been left piling up by the LAMP site in Gebeng. And this waste has, according to groundwater monitoring data revealed in the report of the Executive Review on Lynas, contaminated our groundwater and the surrounding environment since 2015.” Mr Hon added.

Under the Water Services Industry Act (WSIA), contaminating water ways or water supply including groundwater with radioactive substance is considered a national security issue, so much so that it is a serious offence punishable with a maximum jail term of up to ten years, fine up to RM500K and/or whipping. The relevant section of the WSIA is attached for reference.

Mr Hon further lamented “Yet both of our regulators – namely AELB and DoE, supposedly the guardian of our environment and our well-being, paid for by taxpayers, have failed to discharge their responsibilities by strictly enforcing their own regulations. They have failed to protect current and future generations of Malaysians from health risks and threats of livelihoods.”

Lynas’ Toxic Waste is neither Marketable nor Commercially Viable

“Instead, they have continued to side with a foreign company that has the audacity to still propose that its toxic waste be recycled for commercial purposes, despite seven years of failures since it is clearly an unmarketable proposition. Furthermore, Minister Yeo has already decided against the use of the WLP waste in any future trial (See Screenshot 2 on p.5).” Mr Tan added.

In recent months, Malaysia has had a series of disastrous pollution incidents – from the toxic fume in Sungai Kim Kim in Johor, the multiple deaths of Orang Asli to Lynas’ rising piles of waste. These are symptomatic of a systemic and systematic failure of pollution control and toxic waste management; and a government failing to protect those who are most vulnerable and defenseless.

Mr Tan clarified, “SMSL has been vocal on the Lynas issue because we do not want our beautiful Malaysia to become a toxic waste dumping ground of the world.”

Western Australia Can Accept Lynas’ Waste If Lynas Process its Ore Locally

Earlier this week on the 24th June, Mashal Ahmad, Lynas Malaysia’s Vice President and Managing Director has announced that Lynas’ plan to build a leaching and cracking (LnC) plant in WA to remove the radioactive materials from its lanthanide concentrate before sending the feedstock to the LAMP in Malaysia. This proposal will take many years before the plant is operational, even if Lynas can find the money to finance it since it is still struggling to pay off past debt.

“Now, seven years have passed since all of those promises and commitments were made, we hear yet again the very same promises that Lynas can do this and that. Lynas is asking Malaysians once again to believe in its ‘commitment’? Are Malaysians that stupid? Are we so hungry for investment that we are prepared to put at risks our health and that of countless generations of Malaysians to come? Concluded and asked Mr Hon.

According to a Hansard transcript from WA obtained by SMSL, the reason that WA Government has refused to accept Lynas’ waste is because it has preferred for Lynas to process the ore locally. Attached is the transcript for reference.

Mr Tan concluded with a clear message for Minister Yeo, “We urge MESTECC YB Yeo Bee Yin to stand firm by her decisions made last December in the interest of Malaysia, for the health and well-being of local community to reject Lynas’ appeal. Since Lynas is planning to build the LnC plant in WA, then Lynas must start to negotiate with the Government of WA to return the toxic waste to WA to comply with YB Yeo’s decision and to fulfil its own undertakings.” Mr Tan urged.

For further comments, please contact:

· Mr Tan Bun Teet - Hp: +60 179 730 576

· Mr Hon Kai Ping - +60 112 544 7356


Key Facts on AELB’s Failures as a Regulator

· https://www.eco-business.com/news/lynas-bound-to-remove-all-residue/

Back in 2012, then Head of AELB “Raja Datuk Abdul Aziz Raja Adnan said Lynas was legally bound to ensure that all residue was removed and that AELB would enforce it”.

“Raja Datuk Abdul Aziz said the TOL approved to Lynas Malaysia was subject to the conditions imposed, including an additional two under subsection 32(5) of the Atomic Energy Licensing Act.”

· AELB failed to act on Lynas’ violation of licence conditions.

§ 1st February 2012 – AELB approved Lynas’s application for a Temporary Operating Licence (TOL) with a set of pre-conditions, and where necessary, to return the waste to its source – see TOL attachment for details. In truth, Lynas has never fulfilled conditions (i) to (iii) and AELB has never made public any detailed plan for the permanent disposal facility (PDF) including its location, even though a PDF was supposed to be finalised and approved within 10 months from the TOL.

§ AELB went ahead to issue Lynas with a Full-Stage Operating Licence (FSOL) in September 2014 and renew the FSOL in September 2016, still without any details of a PDF or any commercialisation possibility of Lynas’ wastes. DoE would have access to the ground water contamination monitoring data by then but it simply went along with the 3-year FSOL renewal.

AELB Failed to Follow Through Recommendations by the IAEA (related to the WLP waste)

The 2011 IAEA Mission report made it very clear that its assessment has been made specifically for consideration at the pre-operating licensing stage decision making, and cannot be relied on for subsequent stages of operations.

None of the IAEA Reports in 2011 or 2014 has concluded that the Lynas rare earth refinery operation is safe. In fact, IAEA made 11 recommendations for improvement from the 2011 review and made more suggestions from its 2014 follow up mission.

Listed here are examples of the findings, although this is not an exhaustive list. Many suggestions were made by the 2014 IAEA follow-up review mission as there were outstanding issues yet to be satisfactorily addressed by AELB and/or Lynas.

· IAEA’s reference to “low risk” applies to the plant and NOT the WLP waste. In any case the risk refers to cancer risk, a fatal illness which most sane people would do everything to prevent getting. In fact, page 7 of the 2014 IAEA Mission Report has highlighted AELB’s failure to ensure that Lynas’ WLP waste has a safe permanent disposal plan and that Lynas has not updated its Safety Case Analysis of its inadequate WLP waste storage.

· Page 11 of the 2014 IAEA report was scathing of Lynas’ public relation exercise by installing useless radioactivity reading displays instead of seriously monitoring radioactivity of the wastewater discharged from the LAMP into the Balok River.

· Page 9 to 12 outline the incomplete radiological monitoring effort of Lynas and 3 further suggestions for Lynas to improve on its environmental radioactivity monitoring, especially of the aquatic pathway; to provide more detailed modelling of the ecological and public health impacts of radioactive effluents to the Balok River

· Page 13 highlights IAEA’s dissatisfaction with AELB’s poor efforts and basis used to determine and recover from Lynas costs of long-term management of waste including decommissioning and remediation. AELB’s failure will lead to undue financial burden being passed onto Malaysians in the future.

· In page 18, IAEA further emphasized the need for AELB and Lynas to be transparent with the licensing process and to regularly provide updated online information by making key documents accessible to the public.

· In page 20, IAEA suggested that Lynas engaged pro-actively with a wide range of stakeholders including its opponents; and to make available online monitoring data to the public.



Weblinks for the IAEA Reports are as follows:

https://www.australianmining.com.au/news/increase-safety-measures-at-lynas-rare-earths-plant-iaea-say/

https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/news/malaysian-government-releases-iaea-report-lynas-project?fbclid=IwAR1X4SxGEmKKwFMUsFa3ikk8WUX5JktB-_EExkqrS65NMppyiecUS2qxhF8

https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/lynas-report-20052015.pdf



Reference documents

Screen shot 1- from page 2 of the 4th December 2018 Press Release by MESTECC

Decision of the ministry based on the executive review committee report on the operation of the Lynas Advanced Materials Plant (LAMP) in Gebeng,

Pahang two pre-licence conditions imposed by MESTECC in December 2018:





Screen shot 2 : from page 3 of the 4th December 2018 Press Release by MESTECC

Decision of the ministry based on the executive review committee report on the operation of the Lynas Advanced Materials Plant (LAMP) in Gebeng, Pahang

Decision on WLP waste in future trials




[1] Uranium is hazardous both from its radioactivity and its chemical property.


[2] Any material with radioactivity concentration above 1Bq/g under international radiation safety and protection regulatory requirement must be regulated by a competent and independent agency. Lynas’ WLP waste has a radioactivity concentration of between 6 to 8Bq/g, eight times higher than the regulatory limit.

Wednesday, 19 June 2019

SMSL/PSHK Press statement

Lynas is Responsible for the Toxic Heavy metal Groundwater Contamination
19th June 2019



Today, SMSL under the registered name of its parent body, Pertubuhan Solidariti Hijau Kuantan (PSHK), has lodged a police report in response to the serious groundwater contamination as evidenced from data revealed in the report of the Executive Review Committee on Lynas released last December, review of DoE documents and water sampling tests carried out by SMSL since 2016.

Mr Tan Bun Teet, chairman of SMSL said, “Polluting our environment, especially the ground water is an act of crime. Since our regulators have not taken any action and have flaunted their own regulations despite data clearly showing otherwise, we have no choice but to act in the interest of our community and for our country.”

Mr Tan is supported by legal adviser, Mr Hon Kai Ping with the lodgement. Mr Hon explained, ”Contamination of water course including ground water is an offence under the Water Services Industry Act (WSIA). In fact, Parliament has deemed it so serious that under section 121 of the WSIA, if the contamination results in death, the penalty may also be death.”

“The President of the Malaysian Bar has recently made a public statement on these issues (Press Statement attached). Water contamination is a national security issue and our authorities should take the report seriously.” Mr Hon added.

Under WSIA, any party found guilty by the court is subject to a hefty fine of RM500,000 or ten years jail term or both; or the death penalty if the contamination has caused deaths – see the relevant page attached.

Serious groundwater contamination from toxic heavy metals including nickel, lead, chromium and even mercury were evidenced from a set of groundwater data revealed in the ERC report in page 80 and 81.

Nickel, lead, chromium and mercury are all hazardous substances. Lead is particularly harmful to babies and children. World Health Organisation has warned that there is no safe exposure level of lead. For further details on the health hazards of these substances, please refer to the relevant attached documents for reference.

“We lodge the police report because we have waited for over a year since the change of government for the regulators to carry out their duty to enforce the law. Unfortunately, there has not been any improvement within the Department of Environment. They have done nothing to investigate the contamination and below standard wastewater discharged by Lynas. Instead they continue to sing Lynas praises in public at public forum and through the media.”

The contamination data are from Lynas own monitoring stations, surrounding its waste storage facility and its final wastewater discharge point. The maximum recorded contamination level of 96,110 µg/l was from Lynas’ sampling station near its final wastewater discharge point, labelled as GW13. This reading is over 1,200 times higher than the Dutch intervention level of 75 µg/l! That is about 10% of the WLP nickel concentration.

All the nickel data exceeded the Dutch legal limit of 75 µg/l. The few chromium data available in the Table - 31 µg/l to 266 µg/l - exceeded the Dutch intervention limit of 30 µg/l. Similarly, with the lead (Pb) and mercury (Hg) data. These are all toxic elements that will adversely affect our environment with serious implications for community health.

“When Lynas claimed that it has complied with the law, it is the law which DoE/JAS has bent for Lynas. As an Australian corporate entity, Lynas should adhere to the ASX Corporate Governance Principles – especially Principle 3 which requires that it acts ‘ethically and responsibly’ which goes ‘well beyond mere compliance with legal obligations and involves acting with honesty, integrity’ and ‘includes being, and being seen to be, a good corporate citizen, acting responsibly towards the environment.’”[1] Mr Hon added.

No other industry or business anywhere in Malaysia could get away with so much wastes piled up by its plant. With half a million tonnes of waste contaminated with radioactive materials and other toxic substances continuing to contaminate the environment.

The regulatory agency overseeing the Lynas’ environmental management is the Department of Environment or Jabatan Alam Sekitar (DoE/JAS). It is required through its mandated roles and responsibilities under the Environmental Quality Act 1974 to uphold the law and to enforce regulations stated under the Act of Parliament.

Mr Tan and Mr Hon reminded the Government, “Janji 39 of the Pakatan Harapan (PH) manifesto promises that all projects that affect the environment must stand up to the highest standards of environmental protection and that it follows international best practices. The Manifesto also castigated the previous BN administration and stated that the PH government would not bow to big companies and crony capitalism. We hope this would also not be the case here! The whole country is watching!”



For further comments, please contact:

· Mr Tan Bun Teet - Hp: +60 179 730 576

· Mr Hon Kai Ping - +60 112 544 7356

Attachments:

1. Map of groundwater monitoring stations

2. Water Services Industry Act – contamination of water course

3. Health hazards of toxic heavy metals

4. Lynas is responsible for the groundwater contamination




[1] https://www.asx.com.au/documents/asx-compliance/cgc-principles-and-recommendations-3rd-edn.pdf
https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/480278?fbclid=IwAR2o0q7ZiNIQFvuJXUpz-xM5JWsqGeB5kz4km1CAKQKIFR6-EOO-5n_p76I

NGO lodges report against Lynas over groundwater pollution

Published: 19 Jun 2019, 5:41 pm | Modified: 19 Jun 2019, 5:41 pm


NGO Save Malaysia, Stop Lynas (SMSL) lodged a police report today claiming that Lynas Malaysia is responsible for groundwater pollution in the Gebeng area.

They said this is based on, among others, data revealed in the cabinet’s executive review committee report on the rare earth processing plant in Gebeng owned by Australian mining firm Lynas.

Other sources included Environment Department documents and water sampling tests carried out by SMSL since 2016.

"Since our regulators have not taken any action and have flouted their own regulations despite data clearly showing otherwise, we have no choice but to act in the interest of our community and for our country.

"We lodge the police report because we have waited for over a year since the change of government for the regulators to carry out their duty to enforce the law," SMSL chairperson Tan Bun Teet said in a statement after lodging the police report in Kuantan this morning.

"Unfortunately, there has not been any improvement within the Environment Department. They have done nothing to investigate the contamination and below-standard wastewater discharged by Lynas.

"Instead they continue to sing Lynas’ praises in public at public forums and through the media."




SMSL legal adviser Hon Kai Ping stated that contamination of water, including groundwater, is an offence under the Water Services Industry Act 2006.

“In fact, Parliament has deemed it so serious that under Section 121 of the act, if the contamination results in death, the penalty may also be death," he said.

Water contamination, Hon added, is a national security issue and the authorities should take the issue seriously.

"No other industry or business anywhere in Malaysia could get away with so much waste piled up by its plant," SMSL said.

Malaysiakini is contacting Lynas for their response.

Harapan's manifesto pledges

SMSL reminded the Pakatan Harapan government that its election manifesto promises that all projects affecting the environment must stand up to the highest standards of environmental protection and follow international best practices.

The manifesto also promised that the Harapan government would not bow to big companies and crony capitalism, the group said.

“We hope this would also not be the case here. The whole country is watching,” it added.

SMSL quoted from the executive review committee’s report, which said that the groundwater in the Gebeng area surrounding the Lynas plant was contaminated with toxic heavy metals such as nickel, lead, chromium and mercury.



However, in late May this year, Water, Land and Natural Resources Minister Dr Xavier Jayakumar said the groundwater in Gebeng is no longer polluted by heavy metals.

“The latest tests that were done around the Lynas area gave us negative readings of heavy metals.

“This was done by my department and we did not find anything that is polluting in that area,” he had said.

Energy, Science, Technology, Environment and Climate Change Ministry deputy secretary-general Nagulendran Kangayatkarasu said a day later that the spike in heavy metals in the groundwater around the Lynas plant in Gebeng did not originate from the facility.

It is now under permissible levels, he said.

Nagulendran said the spike noted by the cabinet review committee's report was a one-off incident, and the ministry is prepared to publish the data to show that the heavy metal levels have gone down.

He added although the source of the spike is still unknown, continuous monitoring has managed to rule out Lynas as a contributor.

Despite the deputy secretary-general's assertion that the ministry is ready to publish the findings, Nagulendran and the Environment Department have not responded to Malaysiakini's multiple requests for the data.

Tuesday, 11 June 2019

https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2019/06/12/lynas-poses-risk-of-another-bukit-merah-tragedy-says-green-group/

Lynas poses risk of another 80’s radioactive tragedy, says green group

PETALING JAYA: The Malaysian Nature Society (MNS) has warned of a repeat of the Bukit Merah tragedy if the government exempts Lynas Malaysia from laws to control radioactive waste.

Jehan Bakar, who heads the Pahang chapter of MNS, said the people of Kuantan were at risk of suffering the kind of contamination that affected the people of Bukit Merah in the 1980s.

Large amounts of thorium hydroxide were discovered in 1984 in Papan, a village just outside Bukit Merah. Investigations revealed that the radioactive waste originated from a rare earth factory set up in 1979.

Children in the area were found to have high levels of lead in their blood. Clinical tests found that some of them had cancer and auto-immune diseases.

“Do we never learn from history?” said Jehan.

“Lynas needs to clean up its act. Otherwise it will be Bukit Merah all over again.”

She alleged that Lynas was in violation of a licensing regulation requiring it to dispose of radioactive waste within a year of its production.

“It has five to six years’ worth of waste behind its plant now,” she told FMT. “Why is it getting special treatment?”

She said Lynas, “with more than one billion tonnes of waste aged more than 180 days” stored behind the factory, was defying the Environmental Quality Regulations (Scheduled Waste) of 2005, which limits the quantity to 20 tonnes and the storage period to 180 days.

“They get 12 years of tax relief, and they get to flout our laws,” she added.

She rejected Lynas’ proposal for the recycling of the waste, saying it should not be used in public areas because of its radioactive nature.

Jehan also alleged that the Department of Environment was not doing its job as a protector of the environment. “It’s more of an enabler or accessory to a corporation.”

She urged the people of Kuantan to refuse to let others decide what would be in their backyard, and voiced support for Kuantan MP Fuziah Salleh for her consistent statement against allowing Lynas to continue operating in the country.

Another environmentalist, Anthony Tan, described the waste from the Lynas plant as a ticking bomb.

“It may take five years, it may take 100 years for health signs to manifest, but radioactive waste is radioactive waste,” he said.

Asked to comment on suggestions that the waste be used as fertiliser, he said Australia, Lynas’ home country, should take the lead.

“Let them use the fertiliser widely in Australia first,” he said.

Last month, Dr Mahathir Mohamad said Malaysia would allow Lynas to keep operating its rare earth processing plant in Gebeng, which lies on the outskirts of Kuantan.

The prime minister’s statement removed the uncertainty over the future of the US$800 million plant after Malaysia halted the process for renewal of its licence.
https://www.facebook.com/YBFuziahSalleh/posts/1158521477649511

https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/479034

Fuziah: Lynas not in the clear over dangerous residue just yet

Lynas Malaysia Sdn Bhd is not in the clear over producing dangerous residue just yet, according to Kuantan MP Fuziah Salleh.

Fuziah said this is because groundwater contamination detection requires a "protracted, regular and technically reliable independent monitoring strategy".

"A conclusion can only be made with a high level of statistical confidence based on multiple and repeated samples taken across seasons to adjust for possible seasonal effects," she said in a statement today.

"This kind of pollution has very serious public and environmental health implications in the long run."

Fuziah was responding to Lynas claiming last week that its critics were proven wrong in saying that its Gebeng operations produced a dangerous residue.

This followed Water, Land and Natural Resources Minister Dr Xavier Jayakumar saying last month that the groundwater around the Lynas plant is no longer polluted by heavy metals.




Energy, Science, Technology, Environment and Climate Change Ministry deputy secretary-general Nagulendran Kangayatkarasu also said the spike in heavy metal readings in the groundwater around the Gebeng plant did not originate from Lynas.

"These statements are consistent with Lynas Malaysia's own groundwater monitoring and analysis," the company insisted.

In her statement, Fuziah said Lynas has persistently denied that its operations have caused serious heavy metal contamination – even when data taken over a 12-month period from September 2015 from its own groundwater monitoring stations have shown otherwise.

“Of course, Lynas would never have admitted to the contamination, because if it does, then it will be liable for this pollution.

"As a speculative rare earth junior mining company, its future lies in its ability to mask the real problems it is facing in Malaysia," she said.

"Simply branding people who have raised concerns about its pollution and waste as activists underestimates the many experts from different fields whom I have met over the years.

"These are highly skilled educated professionals with post-graduate qualifications from various reputable universities in Malaysia and from advanced industrialised countries overseas.

"They have given their pro bono professional advice out of their sense of duty to the country and for our rakyat and because they feel that Malaysia deserves the truth and environmental justice."

Fuziah also pointed out that Lynas' waste contains naturally occurring radioactive materials (Norm), which is considered radioactive in Australia.

“Many poisons are naturally occurring also, and if any of it is released into our environment or our body, we will be poisoned.

"The same logic can be applied to Lynas’ Norm waste," she said.