Friday, 8 March 2013

Lynas’ Appeal in Defamation Case Dismissed with RM20K costs

Save Malaysia! Stop Lynas! Press statement

March 8th, 2013

This morning, three judges unanimously dismissed Lynas' appeal with costs of RM20,000.00 in its defamation proceeding against SMSL. Last July, Lynas failed in its attempt to gag SMSL through an injunction application. Lynas alleged that an open letter issued by SMSL which was endorsed by close to 50 civil society organisations to the Prime Minister was defamatory. Subsequently, SMSL lawyer succeeded in getting the court to transfer the case to be heard in Kuantan which led to the Lynas appeal.

Mr Tan Bun Teet, a spokesperson for SMSL, a Kuantan resident and a defendant named in the defamation suit said “In the first place, by taking up a defamation action against a citizen group such as SMSL, Lynas’ is showing itself up the kind of corporation it really is. We raise issues concerning the Lynas rare earth project with our Prime Minister because we are concerned for our family and our future. Lynas would not be able to sue us this way in Australia and yet it is taking advantage of Malaysia’ weak civil rights law to try to gag us.”

The judges ruled that the High Court judge was correct in deciding to transfer the case to the Kuantan High Court because it is an appropriate forum for the case. The Judges were:-
Justice Hishammuddin Yunus
Justice Abd Aziz Rahim, and
Justice Mohd Ariff Yusof

Haji Ismail Abu Bakar, another defendant named in the Lynas suit and a Kuantan resident explained, “I speak out because many rakyat (citizens) who will be directly and most immediately affected by Lynas’ pollution are at no liberty to speak out or to voice their concerns. They may lose their livelihoods and our health may suffer severely. We have never been consulted about this project. Lynas’ gag action only strengthened my determination to keep fighting.”

In January, reputable Germany’s Oeko Institute released a detailed scientific evaluation of the Malaysian Lynas rare earth refinery plant and found several very serious deficiencies which should have been identified by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and the Malaysian regulators the Department of Environment and the Atomic Energy Licensing Board (AELB). Instead, approval was given to the project and an operating licence issued which will lead to dire consequences to the local community and future generations:

“These agencies which are supposedly set up to protect the public and the environment have failed us. We the affected citizens have no choice but to pick up the pieces and to fight for our future through legitimate means and way. We have said it many times, we will fight till the end to Stop Lynas.” Concluded Mr Tan.


  1. Lynas has only lost in its request to move the defamation case from Kuantan.

    There is nothing wrong with concerned citizens about the environment our health, this is a good thing, but what Lynas is taking SMSL and its directors to court for is because they made up lies and misrepresented the truth.

    They in fact have every right to take the SMSL liars to court. If someone or some group made lies up about me in a public forum I would also take them to court.

    The SMSL already owe Lynas more than RM20,000 when it lost to Lynas in the last court case. Had SMSL paid that to Lynas yet?

    SMSL had failed its people by lying to them and the truth continues to be realised.

    Go Lynas Go

    What a joke for the supporters of the SAVE MALAYSIA STOP LYNAS..

  3. The defamation case will still be heard and Mr Tan stands to lose everything. Lies have a habit of catching up with you and Mr Tans time of reckoning is fast approaching, bring it on we can't wait.Even Anwar and Wong Tack have changed sides perhaps they realised the the compenstion costs of closing Lynas down is much more than Malaysia can ever afford

  4. Saving moneyCheers a great deal pertaining to discussing! An individual offer lots of valuable tips. Fiscal setting up is vital and everyone have to do the item - even begin young. Although, it's both equally crucial that you learn that you have solutions when individuals will need income fast including obtaining. Saving time and Saving energy

  5. If you want your ex-girlfriend or ex-boyfriend to come crawling back to you on their knees (even if they're dating somebody else now) you got to watch this video
    right away...

    (VIDEO) Get your ex CRAWLING back to you...?